The Short Answer
Universal life premiums go up because the policy’s internal cost of insurance charge climbs every year as you age, while the interest credited to your cash value has earned far less than the 7 to 12 percent the original illustration projected. When the cash value can no longer cover those rising monthly charges, the insurer demands a higher premium to keep the policy in force. Many carriers also raised internal charges outright, a pattern that has produced hundreds of millions of dollars in class action settlements. You have six real options, and the worst thing you can do is let the policy quietly lapse.
If you are reading this because the letter announcing an increase just arrived, you are not misunderstanding it and you are not alone. The premium on a universal life insurance policy you have paid for 25 years really can double or triple this way, and it has happened to millions of policyholders. This guide walks through the mechanics in plain English, the rights most policyholders never hear about, and all six options. Take your time reading it. No decision you make today needs to be made today.
You can sell a life insurance policy, not just cancel it.
Cancel it, and the insurance company pays you a set amount. Sell it, and an institution buys the policy from you, often for far more. There is no upfront cost to find out what yours is worth.
Why Your Premium Is Going Up
Three things went wrong at the same time, and every universal life policy sold between the 1980s and the early 2000s is feeling the effects.
1. Interest Rates Collapsed
Universal life policies have an internal savings account called the cash value. Your insurance company credits interest to that account, and the growth of the cash value is what is supposed to help cover your insurance costs as you age.
Policies sold in the 1980s and 1990s were illustrated at crediting rates of 7 to 12 percent. After 2008, prevailing interest rates collapsed, and most universal life policies have been earning only their guaranteed minimum of 2 to 4 percent ever since. The difference compounds viciously across 25 or 30 years. A policy illustrated to have $200,000 in cash value by year 25 may actually have $40,000. A policy designed to carry itself through your 80s may run out in your 70s.
2. Cost of Insurance Charges Went Up
Inside every universal life policy is a monthly charge called the cost of insurance, or COI. The COI pays for the actual death benefit, and unlike a whole life premium, it rises every year as you age.
When interest rate earnings dropped and cash values stopped growing as projected, insurance companies responded by raising COI charges on existing policies. The class action cases detailed below document increases of 25 percent to over 70 percent, often on policies owned by seniors over 70 with face amounts above $1 million. Plaintiffs have alleged these increases were outside what the original contracts permitted. Some courts have agreed, calling certain insurer interpretations “absurd.”
3. The Original Illustration Was Never a Guarantee
When a universal life policy is sold, the agent walks the buyer through a printed illustration that projects how the policy will perform over time. These illustrations are based on assumptions about interest rates, investment earnings, and insurance costs. They are not guarantees, and the fine print always said so, but most policyholders reasonably believed that the number at the bottom of the page was what the policy would actually do.
Here is a side-by-side comparison of what policyholders were typically shown in the 1990s versus what actually happened.
| What the 1995 Illustration Showed | What Actually Happened | |
|---|---|---|
| Crediting rate | 7 to 10 percent | 3 to 4 percent (guaranteed floor) |
| Annual premium to age 95 | Roughly $4,200 | Climbs to $15,000 to $25,000 in later years |
| Cash value at year 25 | $180,000 to $250,000 | $30,000 to $60,000 |
| Cost of insurance | Stable scale | Increased by 25 to 70 percent on many blocks |
When all three factors line up, the result is what the industry privately calls an underfunded or zombie universal life policy. The cash value is being eaten faster than premiums can rebuild it, and without additional payments the policy is scheduled to lapse, often before the insured’s actual life expectancy. Lapsing is exactly how seniors forfeit a policy’s market value: see our state-by-state estimates of what seniors leave on the table by letting life insurance lapse.
This Has Happened to Millions of Policyholders
Every major universal life carrier in the country has been sued in a class action over the way it raised internal charges on in-force policies. Each of those lawsuits has settled, or is currently in settlement negotiations, for tens or hundreds of millions of dollars.
Major Class Action Settlements on Universal Life Premium Increases
| Insurance Company | Amount Paid to Policyholders | Policies Affected |
|---|---|---|
| AXA Equitable | Up to $307.5 million | Athena Universal Life II (2015 increases of 25% to 70%) |
| Transamerica | More than $250 million across three settlements | Universal life policies with 2015 and 2016 increases, TransUltra 115, TransSurvivor 115, and 2022 and 2023 increases |
| John Hancock | Up to $123 million | Performance UL (increase announced in 2018) |
| Lincoln National | $117.75 million ($110 million after opt-outs) | Former Jefferson-Pilot UL (2016 and 2017 increases) |
| ReliaStar Life (Voya) | $39 million | Certain ReliaStar universal life policies |
| Security Life of Denver (former ING and Voya) | $30 million | Strategic Accumulator Universal Life (2015 increase of 42.3%) |
| Voya (former Aetna policies) | $92.5 million | Former Aetna universal life policies (2016 increase) |
| Genworth | $25 million | Certain Genworth universal life policies |
| Symetra | $32.5 million | Certain Symetra universal life policies |
| Pacific Life | $58 million | PDX indexed universal life (illustration-related) |
| US Financial Life (AXA subsidiary) | $28 million | 2015 cost-of-insurance increase |
A note on what this means for you. Most of these settlements are closed to new claims, and those still open apply to narrow policy forms from specific years. Individual payouts, even for automatically included class members, have been modest. The value of this data is different: it documents that the pattern you are experiencing is real, widespread, and serious enough that the country’s largest insurers have collectively paid close to a billion dollars to resolve it. This is not bad luck, and it is not your fault. It is a documented industry pattern, and it changes every conversation you have from here.
If you want to read the public record for your carrier, the settlement websites still online are: Lincoln (former Jefferson-Pilot policies), AXA Equitable, and Transamerica (Handorf). The John Hancock and Voya settlement sites were taken down after those cases closed. Think of them as investigative references, not claim portals.
Premium Increases by Insurance Company
Several of these settlements froze further rate increases for a set number of years, and those freezes end. We keep separate guides for these companies:
- Transamerica. Three rounds of monthly deduction rate increases (2015 and 2016, 2017 and 2018, and 2022 and 2023), each followed by a class settlement and a temporary freeze. See our Transamerica policy guide.
- John Hancock. Performance Universal Life increases announced in 2018, with a freeze of at least five years that runs to about May 2027. See our John Hancock policy guide.
- Lincoln Financial. 2016 and 2017 increases on former Jefferson-Pilot policies, plus a second settlement still before the court. See our Lincoln Financial policy guide.
- ReliaStar and Security Life of Denver. The ING and Voya life insurance policies now serviced by Resolution Life. See our ReliaStar and Security Life of Denver guide.
- Any other company. Our life insurance company directory lists who holds each policy today and the number to call.
What to Do First: A 4-Step Checklist
Before you make any decision, before you respond to the insurance company’s letter, and before you pick any of the options later in this guide, do these four things in this order. None of them commit you to anything, and the first is usually available once a year without charge.
Step 1: Request an In-Force Illustration
State insurance regulators work from a model rule written by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, Model Regulation 582. Under it, an insurer must provide a current in-force illustration when the policy owner asks, and owners of covered policies can request one a year without charge. If yours has not arrived within 30 days, the model rule’s notice says to contact your state insurance department.
An in-force illustration is a printed projection showing exactly where your policy stands right now and exactly how long it will last under different assumptions. Ask for three versions:
- Your current premium continued, on both current and guaranteed assumptions. The guaranteed version uses the worst-case crediting rate and the maximum allowed cost of insurance, so it is your floor. The current version uses today’s rates, so it is your realistic timeline.
- The level premium needed to keep the policy in force to maturity.
- No more premiums paid, so you can see when the policy would end.
If you are thinking about lowering the death benefit, ask for a version at the lower amount too. Those illustrations will tell you more about your actual situation than any phone call with the insurance company ever will. Put the request in writing. Keep a copy. Our in-force illustration guide shows how to read one.
Step 2: Look Up the Case Record for Your Carrier
Take your policy’s product name from the annual statement and compare it to the policy forms named in the settled cases listed earlier. Here is what the exercise will tell you, and what it will not.
- If your policy form appears in a settled case, you now have the clearest public record of how your carrier approached COI increases on your class of policies. That is useful background for any conversation you have with the insurer, a fiduciary, or an attorney.
- Do not expect a class action to solve a current premium problem. Most of these cases are closed to new claims, and class members who were automatically included typically received modest individual payouts. Some settlements did include non-monetary relief like multi-year freezes on further COI increases, which is meaningful, but that relief applies to a specific block of policies from a specific period.
- If your policy is not in any known settled class, your situation is not necessarily different. The underlying mechanics are the same across carriers, and the rights in the remaining steps apply regardless of whether a lawsuit has been filed over your specific policy form.
The goal of this step is context, not compensation. Knowing whether your carrier has already been to court over the same issue changes the texture of every other conversation you have from here.
Step 3: Do Not Call the Insurance Company’s Retention Line Yet
When a policyholder responds to an increase notice, they are often routed to the carrier’s retention or conservation department. These departments are trained to keep the policy on the books with the smallest concession possible, usually a modified premium arrangement or a death benefit reduction. That might be the right answer, but the retention representative is not going to lay out all six of your options or show you what a competitive market would pay for the policy.
Request the in-force illustration first. Read it. Come back to the conversation with numbers.
Step 4: Get a Second Opinion from a Fiduciary
The agent who sold you the policy is not a fiduciary, and neither is the representative on the retention line. A fiduciary is someone with a legal duty to act in your interest, not in the interest of the insurance company. That can mean a fiduciary-licensed life settlement broker, a fee-only financial planner, or an elder-law attorney.
A fiduciary can help you interpret the in-force illustration, evaluate every option on its merits, and catch pressure tactics or unsuitable recommendations. There is no obligation in getting a second opinion.
Your Six Real Options
Before you look at the options, decide what you actually want. Policyholders in this situation usually fall into one of three groups.
- Group A: You want to keep some death benefit for heirs, but you want to stop the rising premium.
- Group B: You want to reduce the premium bill, and keep the policy in some form.
- Group C: You want to get cash out, because the coverage no longer serves a purpose.
Each option below fits one or more of those goals. The right answer depends on which group you are in.
Option 1: Pay the Increase
You can pay the increased premium. For some policyholders with strong retirement income and a clear reason to keep the coverage, this is the right call.
Best when: You still need the full death benefit, you can comfortably absorb the new premium, and the in-force illustration shows the policy will actually last long enough to matter.
Watch out for: Increases that will compound. A 40 percent jump this year often signals that more COI increases are coming, and your in-force illustration will show whether the new premium schedule is stable or just the first step up.
Option 2: Reduce the Death Benefit
Most universal life policies allow you to lower the face amount, which directly reduces the cost of insurance charges. A $1 million policy cut to $400,000 can often become affordable again, and you keep some coverage for heirs.
Best when: Group A or B. You want some death benefit, but not the original amount, and you want the premium bill to go down.
Watch out for: Partial surrender tax consequences if the reduction also pulls out cash value above your cost basis.
Option 3: 1035 Exchange to Guaranteed Universal Life
Internal Revenue Code Section 1035 permits a tax-free exchange of your existing universal life policy’s cash value into a new policy, usually a Guaranteed Universal Life (GUL) policy that locks in both the premium and the death benefit to a specific age, typically 95, 100, or 121. A GUL is effectively permanent term insurance. It carries no cash value build-up, but it also does not blow up the way a traditional UL can.
Best when: You are still insurable, you want predictability, and leaving a fixed death benefit matters more than maximizing cash.
Watch out for: The new policy requires fresh medical underwriting. If your health has changed since the original policy was issued, you may not qualify, or the new death benefit may have to be lower. Also be wary of an agent recommending a replacement purely to earn a new commission. That practice is called churning and is restricted under NAIC Model Regulation 613.
Option 4: Reduced Paid-Up Insurance
Your existing cash value is used to purchase a smaller, fully paid-up death benefit, and you stop paying premiums entirely. A $500,000 policy with $60,000 in cash value might convert to a paid-up policy worth roughly $90,000 to $130,000 in death benefit, depending on age and policy terms.
Best when: Group A. You want to stop paying forever, and you want to leave something behind.
Watch out for: The reduced death benefit may be much smaller than you originally expected. Ask the insurer exactly what the paid-up face amount would be before you commit.
Option 5: Surrender the Policy
You cancel the policy and receive the cash surrender value, which is usually a fraction of what the policy is actually worth. Surrender charges may still apply on newer policies, though they have typically expired on anything held more than 15 or 20 years.
Best when: Group C, but only as a last resort. You need cash quickly, the policy does not qualify for a life settlement, and you have ruled out everything above.
Watch out for: On a struggling universal life policy, the cash surrender value has often been depleted by rising cost-of-insurance charges, so the check may be surprisingly small. Gains above your cost basis are taxed as ordinary income.
Option 6: Sell the Policy Through a Life Settlement
A life settlement is the sale of your policy to a third-party buyer on the open market. You receive a lump-sum payment, and the buyer becomes the new policy owner and takes over future premiums. According to the Life Insurance Settlement Association, sellers in 2025 received an average of nearly 9 times what the insurance company would have paid them in surrender value: $212,066 versus a $24,360 average surrender.
Best when: Group C. You are 65 or older, the face amount is $100,000 or more, the coverage no longer serves a clear purpose, and you want to recover the most possible value from an asset you were considering giving up anyway.
Watch out for: The process takes 60 to 90 days. You give up the death benefit entirely. And proceeds above the cash surrender value are generally taxed, though often at the more favorable long-term capital gains rate rather than as ordinary income.
When rising premiums are the reason you are considering a sale, Citizens Life Group reviews your current in-force illustration and premium notices. Those help show the costs a buyer would take on. If the policy is a candidate, we prepare it for institutional buyers and negotiate competing offers to help maximize what you receive.
For the policy details buyers review, see our guide to selling a universal life insurance policy.
The One Option to Avoid
The worst thing you can do is stop paying and let the policy lapse quietly. A lapse gives you nothing. No cash, no coverage, no further recourse. And because a lapsed policy may still carry a tax liability on policy loans, some seniors are left with a small tax bill on top of getting nothing. Almost any of the six options above is better than walking away.
Red Flags to Watch For
Not everyone who is about to give you advice on your universal life policy has your interests in mind. Here are the warning signs.
- Pressure to decide quickly. No legitimate option requires a same-day decision. If someone is telling you that you have to act within 24 or 48 hours, stop and get a second opinion.
- A “solution” offered without an in-force illustration. If the insurance company is proposing a premium modification or a reduced paid-up conversion and has not handed you a current in-force illustration, ask for one before you sign anything. You are entitled to it.
- An agent recommending you replace the policy. Replacing an old policy with a new one often triggers a fresh commission for the agent. Some replacements are genuinely in the client’s interest. Others are churning. Always ask: what is the commission on the replacement? What is the surrender charge on the new policy? Why is this better than keeping the existing contract?
- “Senior specialist” designations. Several well-known senior-focused designations can be obtained with a short online course and carry no meaningful credential. Verify the producer’s actual state insurance license and look for fiduciary credentials like CFP or fee-only advisor status.
- A cash value that is falling faster than your premium payments, or an annual statement showing the “projected year policy lapses” within your realistic life expectancy. Those are signs the policy is in a death spiral, and every year you wait reduces your options.
Your Consumer Protection Rights
You have more rights than the insurance company’s letter suggested. These are the ones most policyholders do not know about.
- An in-force illustration once a year without charge on covered policies, under NAIC Model Regulation 582, the model rule state regulators work from.
- The right to file a complaint with your state Department of Insurance. Every state has a consumer complaint process. Start at the NAIC consumer portal and follow the link to your state. A DOI complaint can trigger a market conduct review and, in some cases, force the insurer to the table.
- Class action opt-in rights. As noted earlier, if your policy is part of a certified class, you may already be a class member.
- Grace period and reinstatement rights. Most universal life contracts provide a 61-day grace period after a premium shortfall before the policy technically lapses, and most permit reinstatement within three to five years of a lapse if you can provide evidence of insurability and pay the back-due charges. A policy is often not as gone as the insurance company has suggested.
- Replacement disclosure rights under NAIC Model Regulation 613. Any producer recommending you replace an existing policy must provide a written replacement notice and retain records of suitability analysis.
State insurance regulators have specifically warned the public about this issue. The New York Department of Financial Services, the Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance, the Maryland Insurance Administration, and the Oregon Division of Financial Regulation have all issued consumer alerts urging universal life policyholders to request in-force illustrations annually and to understand that the product requires ongoing monitoring. If you suspect an improper sale or an unjustified increase, reach out to your state’s consumer services line.
When a Life Settlement Is the Right Answer, and When It Is Not
For many seniors facing a universal life premium increase, a life settlement is the option that recovers the most value. For others, it is the wrong tool. Both are true, and an honest guide should say so.
- You are 65 or older, and the insured's health has changed since the policy was issued.
- The face amount is $100,000 or more. Smaller policies rarely attract competitive offers.
- You no longer need the death benefit for its original purpose. The kids are grown, the mortgage is paid, the spouse has other resources.
- The policy is an underfunded universal life. The cash surrender value is low and the alternative to selling is surrender or lapse.
- A spouse or disabled dependent genuinely still relies on the death benefit.
- The policy is being used intentionally for estate liquidity or a specific estate planning purpose, unless it is a survivorship policy and one insured has died.
- The policyholder is already in a qualified class action that is producing non-monetary relief such as a COI freeze.
- The policy is small, fully paid-up, and costs nothing to hold. If it pays eventually, that is a bonus for the heirs.
For a policy that does fit the settlement profile, the difference in outcomes is often dramatic. A $500,000 universal life policy held by a 78-year-old in moderate health, with $18,000 of cash surrender value and a premium about to increase by 40 percent, might produce a competitive settlement offer somewhere between $90,000 and $125,000. The exact number depends on health, policy structure, and the buyer’s internal return requirements. You can see a broader breakdown of typical ranges in our average life settlement payout guide.
What to Do This Week
If you are reading this because of a letter you received in the last few days, here is a simple order of operations.
- Today: File the in-force illustration request in writing with your insurance company.
- This week: Look up your policy’s product name against the class action settlement websites listed earlier.
- In the next 30 days: When the in-force illustration arrives, review it carefully. Ask a fiduciary to help you interpret it if the numbers are not clear. Compare your real options side by side before you respond to the insurance company.
- If a life settlement fits your situation: Request an estimate with no obligation. A licensed broker shops your policy to multiple institutional buyers, the buyers bid against each other, and you review the offers with no cost to you. The broker is compensated by a commission from the settlement proceeds at closing.
Whatever you decide, make the decision on your timeline, with complete information, and without pressure. You have more options than the insurance company’s letter made it sound. To get a free policy estimate on https://www.citizenslifegroup.com, use the form on our homepage or call (321) 270-0279.
Sources
- NAIC Model Regulation 582, Life Insurance Illustrations. The model rule state regulators work from. It provides for one in-force illustration a year without charge on covered policies and sets the content requirements for universal life illustrations.
- NAIC Model Regulation 613, Replacement of Life Insurance and Annuities. Requires written replacement disclosures and suitability analysis; the baseline rule preventing churning.
- Life Insurance Settlement Association Annual Market Data. Source for the settlement-versus-surrender multiples (6.5 times in 2024, cited in the embedded video; nearly 9 times in 2025) and the estimate that more than 11 million policies with over $754 billion in face value are surrendered or lapsed each year in the United States.
- In re Lincoln National COI Litigation, $117.75 million settlement. Final approval on October 5, 2023 covering 2016 and 2017 COI increases on former Jefferson-Pilot universal life policies. The cash fund was $109.96 million after opt-outs, with a five-year rate freeze.
- Brach Family Foundation v. AXA Equitable, settlement of up to $307.5 million. Settlement of claims over 2015 COI increases of 25 to 70 percent on Athena Universal Life II policies, with final approval in October 2023.
- Leonard v. John Hancock, settlement of up to $123 million. Settlement covering Performance UL COI increases announced in 2018, approved in May 2022, including a five-year COI freeze. The official settlement site is offline; this is an archived copy.
- Consumer Watchdog legal victories. Consumer Watchdog’s record of its cases, including the earlier Transamerica cost-of-insurance litigation.
- Handorf v. Transamerica settlement site. Official site for the settlement covering the increases that began in 2022.
- New York State Department of Financial Services, Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance Consumer Alert (December 2021), Maryland Insurance Administration Universal Life Advisory, and Oregon Division of Financial Regulation UL Premium Guidance. State regulator consumer alerts urging universal life policyholders to request in-force illustrations annually.
- Internal Revenue Code Section 1035. Federal statute permitting tax-free exchange of existing life insurance policies into other qualifying life insurance or annuity contracts.